Cheap Christmas Dessert Recipes

639 cheap Christmas dessert recipes under $2 a serving, ready in about 88 minutes on average.

639 recipesDessert ×Christmas ×Under $2 a serving ×Clear all

Narrow further+ Healthy + Cheap + Popular + Under 30 mins + High protein + Low carb

Serves 12$1.90 a serving

Frozen Grand Marnier Torte with Dark Chocolate Crust and Spiced Cranberries

Ready in 45 mins

Serves 8$1.72 a serving

Fruited Bread Pudding with Eggnog Sauce

Ready in 60 mins

Quick

Serves 14$0.28 a serving

Sugar Cookie Chex® Party Mix

Ready in 15 mins

Serves 16$0.75 a serving

Candy Cane Crunch Krispie Treats

Ready in 45 mins

Serves 6$1.84 a serving

Snowy owl Christmas tree biscuits

Ready in 75 mins

Serves 10$0.56 a serving

Christmas Pudding with Brandy Sauce

Ready in 45 mins

Serves 28$0.48 a serving

Vegan Christmas Fruitcake

Ready in 45 mins

Serves 6$0.96 a serving

Rice Pudding with Persimmons and Dried Cranberries

Ready in 45 mins

Serves 4$1.41 a serving

Fruitcake Trifle

Ready in 45 mins

Serves 8$0.74 a serving

Christmas Rice Pudding

Ready in 60 mins

Serves 9$0.64 a serving

Old-Fashioned Gingerbread

Ready in 65 mins

Serves 18$0.64 a serving

Gingerbread Cupcakes

Ready in 85 mins

Serves 12$0.75 a serving

Gingerbread Poke Cake

Ready in 120 mins

Serves 15$0.99 a serving

Matzo Crisp with Pear, Apple and Cranberries

Ready in 60 mins

Serves 8$1.27 a serving

Eggnog Cream Pie

Ready in 240 mins

Serves 15$1.64 a serving

Chocolate gingerbread brownie bars with fudgy icing

Ready in 55 mins

Serves 16$0.61 a serving

Fruitcake Bars

Ready in 45 mins

Serves 4$1.41 a serving

Fruitcake Trifle

Ready in 45 mins

Serves 8$1.46 a serving

Golden Delicious Apple and Cheddar Turnovers with Dried Cranberries

Ready in 45 mins

Serves 8$0.42 a serving

Cranberry Eggnog Cornbread Scones

Ready in 35 mins

Serves 24$0.35 a serving

Christina Tosi's Christmas Treats

Ready in 30 mins

Serves 10$1.62 a serving

Dark Chocolate and Peppermint Whipped Cream Tart

Ready in 45 mins

Serves 10$1.04 a serving

Hazelnut fruitcake

Ready in 100 mins

Serves 4$0.57 a serving

Similar to Potbelly Sugar Cookies

Ready in 22 mins

Load More Recipes

Showing 24 of 639

All Filters

Ingredients

Course

Time

Diet

Cuisine

Equipment

Serves

1–2 people8,1443–4 people30,5185–6 people22,0887+ people53,647

Cost per serving

Under $1 a serving47,633Under $2 a serving78,933Under $3 a serving95,528

Nutrition

Calories per serving

High protein (20g+)34,534Low carb (under 20g)43,426

Rating

★★★★★ 4 & up1★★★★★ 3 & up1★★★★★ 2 & up1

Occasion

Clear All

Cheap Christmas Dessert Recipes

Related collections